Sean McGirr’s debut as the new creative director of Alexander McQueen last March marked a pivotal moment for the brand, stirring mixed reactions across the fashion industry. As he took the reins of one of fashion’s most revered houses, McGirr faced the daunting challenge of living up to the legacy of Alexander McQueen himself, whose visionary designs continue to cast a long shadow. The response to McGirr’s inaugural collection was divided, with many critics and fashion enthusiasts struggling to connect with the bold, sometimes eccentric designs that appeared to depart from the founder’s more poetic yet equally audacious spirit.
One of the most talked-about pieces from McGirr’s debut collection was the Hoof Shoes—a striking design that seemed to push the boundaries of both practicality and imagination. Crafted from pony hair, the boots featured a real horseshoe embedded in the sole and an enameled hoof at the tip, with some versions even incorporating a thick horse tail on the heel. The design drew comparisons to the “horse girl” trend, yet also evoked memories of Alexander McQueen’s deep-rooted fascination with animalistic themes. While the initial reaction to the shoes was mixed, with some dismissing them as overly theatrical, the Hoof Shoes have since begun to gain a cult following, suggesting that McGirr’s vision may be gradually winning over McQueen’s loyal fanbase.
The broader fashion industry’s reception to McGirr’s debut was, however, not without its criticisms. Some industry insiders and fashion critics expressed concern that McGirr’s designs, while innovative, lacked the nuanced depth and storytelling that characterized McQueen’s work. Social media was particularly harsh, with some users labeling McGirr a “mediocre” successor to the brand’s founder. This reaction underscores the immense pressure McGirr faces in filling the shoes of a designer who not only revolutionized fashion but also built a brand identity steeped in dark romanticism and fearless innovation.
Despite the initial backlash, McGirr’s work, especially the Hoof Shoes, could have a lasting impact on McQueen’s brand identity. The design’s daring nature and clear nod to the animal world resonate with the maison’s history of challenging conventional beauty and embracing the macabre. The Hoof Shoes, while controversial, are undeniably a conversation piece, reflecting McQueen’s tradition of pushing the limits of fashion. As McGirr continues to carve out his vision for the brand, these designs could play a crucial role in defining a new era for McQueen—one that honors its past while daring to forge a new path.
Looking at the broader context of animalistic designs in high fashion, McGirr’s approach is far from unprecedented. Designers have long turned to the animal kingdom for inspiration, often as a means to explore the primal and untamed aspects of human nature. Martin Margiela’s iconic tabi boots, which feature a split-toe design reminiscent of cloven hooves, are a prime example of this. Though rooted in Japanese culture, the tabi boots carry an animalistic undertone that challenges the boundaries between fashion and function. Similarly, JW Anderson’s webbed lace-ups for FW23 evoke the image of amphibious creatures, merging the natural world with avant-garde design.
Even within the McQueen brand, animalistic themes have been a recurring motif. During her tenure as creative director, Sarah Burton revisited these themes, though in a more refined and less dramatic manner than McGirr. For the FW12 collection, Burton designed leather and fur ankle boots with metallic soles and platforms that closely echoed McGirr’s Hoof Shoes. However, Burton’s interpretation was softer, with the collection featuring lace, feather boas, hourglass coats, and layers of white and pink tulle. Burton’s work celebrated a “beautiful future, positivity, and optimism,” as she stated, contrasting with McGirr’s more grounded and arguably darker vision.
Fashion experts and industry insiders have offered varied perspectives on the significance of McGirr’s animalistic designs. Some argue that these elements serve as a powerful homage to McQueen’s legacy, tapping into the maison’s long-standing fascination with the animalistic and the otherworldly. Others suggest that McGirr’s approach may be an attempt to critique the current state of the fashion industry—a world that McQueen himself once described as “a jungle full of nasty, bitchy hyenas.” This critique is reflected in the realism and raw energy of McGirr’s designs, which seem to capture the uncertainty and fear that pervade today’s world.
In conclusion, Sean McGirr’s debut collection for Alexander McQueen, marked by the controversial Hoof Shoes, represents a bold attempt to navigate the complex legacy of one of fashion’s most iconic brands. While the collection has sparked debate and division within the fashion community, it also opens up new possibilities for McQueen’s future. By embracing the animalistic themes that have long defined the brand, McGirr is both honoring its past and challenging its present, paving the way for a new chapter in the McQueen story. Whether his vision will ultimately resonate with the brand’s devoted fanbase and the wider fashion industry remains to be seen, but one thing is clear: McGirr’s McQueen is not afraid to confront the wild side of fashion head-on.
curlycurlworld: Get Twisted with CurlyCurl: The Latest in Curls, Coils, and Confidence! 